What quality standards taught me about trust


· 6 min read
This is article 2 of 3 in The Hush series. Here is article 1.
I started my career in the beer business, as an auditor. One check we always ran was to compare current production against the industry’s brewing standards.
That wasn’t paperwork for its own sake. If we drifted from those standards, nobody could guarantee the beer was fit for people to drink.
I assumed all manufacturing worked that way. I was wrong.
As I moved into other industries, I found standards that were vague and hard to read. Some could be rejigged if you had enough money or clout. In many industries, they were a mirage.
A supplier could claim almost anything about quality. A buyer had no easy way to check, short of sending in their own auditors. Big companies could afford that. Small ones couldn’t afford to be checked a dozen different ways by a dozen different customers.
Then I discovered ISO 9000. One international standard, one audit, recognised by customers everywhere, instead of a dozen customers each checking you their own way.
When I first understood it, I saw it for what it was from a business point of view. It was a way to level the playing field for the smaller players.
I annoyed a lot of business owners by pushing them into the certification process. It was work. Writing down how you actually operate is tedious and often humbling. Nobody signed up for fun.
And it paid off, many times over. Revenues grew solidly as new customers flocked to our doors. The certificate told them something they couldn’t otherwise know. Our processes met the same bare minimum as the big players. A small plant could stand beside a large one and say, you can trust us too.
Here’s the part I didn’t fully appreciate at the time. ISO 9000 didn’t succeed because it was a perfect standard. In my experience, it succeeded because buyers started asking for it.
As I see it now, a certificate nobody asks for is a cost. A certificate your best customer requires is a passport. And passports make life a lot easier, don’t they?
Sustainability claims today look a lot like quality claims did before ISO 9000. Words like “green,” “eco-friendly” and “natural” are everywhere. Much like organic food in its early days, before it had firm rules, there’s often no common floor behind them.
Earlier in this series, I wrote about winemakers who stopped talking about their sustainability work. Some said the labels had been watered down until they meant very little. So the honest growers walked away from the words altogether.
Here’s the uncomfortable part. My own region already has a version of this. Ontario’s wine industry runs a sustainability certification for vineyards and wineries, backed by an independent third-party audit.
As of 2024, 37 wineries and 97 vineyards held that certification. Ontario has more than 190 VQA wineries. That’s a real start. It isn’t a level playing field yet.
The difference, from where I sit, is the buyer. ISO 9000 became the price of entry. A sustainability certificate still feels like an optional extra. Until the retailers, restaurants and purchasing offices start asking for it, the honest firms carry the cost, and everyone else carries on.
So how do we turn that certificate into an industry passport?
On September 27, 2026, new European Union rules on green claims came into force. Vague claims such as “environmentally friendly,” “green” or “ecological” are now off limits unless a company can back them with solid evidence. Green labels need a proper certification scheme behind them.
The rules apply to consumer products, including those already on the shelf. In plain business terms, Europe made a floor mandatory for anyone selling to consumers there.
There’s a caution in Europe’s story too. A broader law, which would have required outside checks of environmental claims before they were made, stalled in 2025. Critics worried it was too complex and too costly, especially for small companies.
Canada went the other way. In March 2026, Ottawa amended the Competition Act and narrowed its greenwashing rules. Companies no longer need to use an “internationally recognized methodology” to back up claims about their business. Private parties can no longer bring those complaints forward themselves.
So one side of the Atlantic raised the floor, and the other lowered it, within months of each other. I don’t know which approach will win over time. What I do know, from years on the manufacturing side, is that uncertainty is what makes small firms freeze.
A standard can fail in two directions. Set it too high, and only the big players can afford it. That is the worry that stalled Europe’s broader law. Set it so low that everyone qualifies, and it becomes the watered-down label the winemakers walked away from.
ISO 9000 had its critics too. It proved you followed your own process, not that your process was any good. But it gave small firms something solid to hold on to. In my experience, that mattered more than its flaws.
If I were helping build one, here’s what I’d want to see:
That last point is the hardest, and I don’t think any single company can solve it alone. Who should build the floor, and who should do the asking? I believe that’s where industry associations come in. It’s where I’ll go in the final piece of this series.
illuminem Voices is a democratic space presenting the opinions of leading Sustainability Thought Leaders, their views do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.
The world needs sustainability knowledge. At illuminem, no interest group or shareholder can influence our work. Thank you for supporting our mission to make high-quality and independent sustainability information free for all. Every contribution helps. Thank you for donating today.
Charlene Norman

Corporate Sustainability · Carbon Regulations
illuminem briefings

Corporate Sustainability · Corporate Governance
illuminem briefings

Nature · Sustainable Finance
ESG Today

Nature · Sustainable Finance
Politico

Corporate Sustainability · Carbon
Electrek

Energy · Corporate Sustainability