Why good companies go quiet


· 6 min read
This is article 1 of 3 in The Hush series.
Ten years ago, I left the big city for the country. I live in Niagara now. It’s farms, wineries and flowers as far as I can see.
One of the quiet gifts of living here is talking to the people who grow my food. Ask a farmer about their soil, and you’ll get an education. They’ll tell you about drainage, about what they put back into the land and what they refuse to put on it. Nobody is performing. They’re just telling you how they work.
So, when I read about a Niagara winery that kept its sustainability record out of its marketing on purpose, I paid attention. I’ve watched companies do exactly that for most of my career.
Wren Montgomery, Quinn Professor of Sustainability at Smith School of Business, has spent years studying greenwashing. When a friend told her that a well-known Niagara winery downplayed its strong environmental record and certifications, her first instinct was suspicion. What were they hiding?
Nothing, as it turned out. The winery was doing the best it could on sustainability in a tough, competitive industry. It simply chose not to use that as a selling point.
The practice has a name: greenhushing. Greenwashers talk about environmental work they don’t do. Greenhushers do the work and don’t talk about it.
It isn’t rare. A 2024 Corporate Transparency Index study found that 58 per cent of companies surveyed under-promote their progress on environmental, social and governance measures.
Montgomery and her colleagues, Jennifer Robertson and Catherine Summers, went looking for the reasons. They interviewed winery owners and winemakers in Niagara, California and Oregon, and published their findings in the journal Organization Studies. The usual suspects showed up: fear of investor backlash, political risk, worry about being called hypocrites. Some owners didn’t want to be seen as different, or as “hippies,” by their peers. But underneath all of that, the researchers found something the big data studies had missed. For many owners, the silence was personal.
I want to stay on that point. Most of what I read about greenhushing treats it as a political story. Companies keep their heads down when sustainability becomes a lightning rod.
That part is real. Here in Canada, as I read it, Ottawa loosened its greenwashing rules in 2026 partly because businesses were pulling back. That’s greenhushing, showing up in federal policy.
But politics doesn’t explain a family winery in Niagara. What explains it, according to the study, is anger. Growers who protect their soil, water and ecosystems take exaggerated claims by competitors as a personal insult. One owner said it plainly: “greenwashing pisses me off”. So he stopped talking.
The researchers found the silence took three forms.
Some owners rejected the machinery. Certification and branding cost too much or locked them into rules that didn’t fit how they worked.
Some rejected the rhetoric. Labels had been watered down until almost anyone could carry them, so the honest growers walked away. Instead, they told their story in person, at the cellar door.
And some rejected sustainability as an identity altogether. They wanted to be known for good wine, full stop. Sustainable practice was simply how you made it.
None of this surprised me. I’ve sat in rooms where good news got buried. The reasons always sounded sensible. Protect the reputation. Don’t rock the boat. Stick to what we’re known for.
One client stands out. The company’s president told me, with real pride, that he was a huge community supporter. So, I looked. The website barely mentioned it. Nothing was in the marketing materials. It never came up on customer calls.
I thought I was being lied to. I checked the books.
He wasn’t lying. The company supported its community in many ways, to the tune of 10 per cent of revenue. Ten per cent. And nobody knew.
I felt deflated. Not because he’d done anything wrong, but because he’d hidden one of his company’s strongest signals.
Here’s how I put it to him.
Your customer has to make a choice. All things being equal, you nudge your competitor out, just slightly, because you care about your community and give back to it. Why would you not show that, in a small way, to set your business apart?
I wasn’t asking for a billboard. I was asking him to stop hiding something true.
The wineries in the study had the same blind spot. One executive at a top winery told the researchers his farming costs per acre ran below the industry standard. His vines would now live about 50 years instead of an average of 13.
That isn’t a feel-good story. That’s a return on investment. And it stayed in the vineyard, where no buyer, banker or competitor would ever hear it.
Montgomery sees this as more than a communication problem. She calls it a market failure. When buyers can’t tell which companies have paid the real cost of doing better, the honest ones lose ground to the ones who only talk. In her words, the harm falls on “honest, often smaller, often innovative companies”.
Here’s how I’ve come to see it. When the good ones go quiet, the greenwashers get the stage all to themselves. The silence doesn’t protect the honest company. It hands the conversation to its least honest competitor.
The study tells us why companies go quiet. It doesn’t tell us what to do about it, and I don’t think the answer is louder marketing.
I think it starts with a simpler question. What does your company actually believe in? Not what sounds good in a report. What you’d keep doing even if nobody ever noticed. If you can answer that, you know what’s worth saying.
My client believed in his community. He just didn’t think it counted as business.
In the next piece, I’ll go back to where my career began, auditing in the beer business against standards that kept the product fit to drink. Part of the answer to greenhushing, I believe, is something manufacturers learned decades ago.
illuminem Voices is a democratic space presenting the opinions of leading Sustainability Thought Leaders, their views do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.
The world needs sustainability knowledge. At illuminem, no interest group or shareholder can influence our work. Thank you for supporting our mission to make high-quality and independent sustainability information free for all. Every contribution helps. Thank you for donating today.
Charlene Norman

Sustainable Business · Corporate Sustainability
Cara Williams

Climate Change · Sustainable Finance
Tanmay Arora

Energy Transition · Energy Sources
The Wall Street Journal

Wind · Renewables
Carbon Herald

Carbon Capture & Storage · Carbon
Euronews

Green Tech · Sustainable Business