The UN clarion call for carbon removal with sequestration


· 7 min read
Two UN reports released in October reach alarming conclusions about the global community’s lack of progress in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and the potentially dire implications over the course of this century. The UNFCCC Secretariat released its latest synthesis report on the nationally determined contributions (NDCs) by the Parties to the Paris Agreement, and the United Nations Environment Programme released its annual Emissions Gap Report. In addition to assessing the current state of climate mitigation efforts, the reports draw important conclusions about the critical role of point-source capture of carbon dioxide (carbon capture with sequestration (CCS)) and capture of carbon dioxide from ambient air or ocean water (carbon dioxide removal (CDR)) options. These are the most authoritative and granular recent assessments of the place of CCS/CDR in climate change policy to date by UN institutions. The purpose of this piece is to summarise the treatment of CCS/CDR in these two reports and suggest the way forward.
Under Article 4(9) of the Paris Agreement, the respective Parties to the treaty are required to “communicate a nationally determined contribution (NDC) every five years.” The NDCs reflect a “bottom-up” approach to treaty implementation, and embody the national climate action plans of each Party to achieve the objectives of the Agreement. This includes the adoption of “domestic mitigation measures” with respect to anthropogenic emissions and removals (Art. 4(14)). In late October, the Secretariat to the Agreement released its most recent Synthesis Report, intended to summarise the Parties’ progress in operationalising the treaty’s mandates, as well as barriers and gaps in implementation. The Report captures information from 127 new NDCs submitted by 154 Parties to the Paris Agreement between January 1, 2024, and August 31, 2026.
The lion’s share of the Report focuses on the progress of the Parties in effectuating reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, as well as on several other issues, including adaptation and loss and damage. In the context of greenhouse gas mitigation, the Report concluded that implementation of the Parties’ new NDCs could result in emissions decreasing by 6%-9% from 2019 levels by 2035. However, the Report also projected that holding temperatures to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels would require far more dramatic cuts of approximately 60% by 2035, and that the remaining carbon budget to stay below 2°C is now only 860 GtCO2. The Report concluded that the best estimate of projected warming, based on the Parties’ latest NDCs and their Long-Term Low Emission Development Strategies under Article 4(19) of the Paris Agreement, is a foreboding 1.7–2.3°C.
Increasing recognition that traditional mitigation approaches will prove insufficient to avert crossing critical climatic thresholds has led to a growing focus on the potential role of CCS/CDR in the climate policymaking portfolio. These extremely tepid commitments to CCS and CDR stand in stark contrast to the titanic task ahead of scaling up these technologies to make them “Paris-relevant.” A recent report projected that at least 4 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide would need to be removed from the atmosphere annually by 2050 to meet the Paris Agreement’s temperature goals. However, the central range in that study was 7-9 gigatonnes annually by 2050. Moreover, some studies project the need for as much as 20 gigatonnes of removals per year in the latter half of this century. In the context of CCS, while its role in climate policy has been reduced in recent modelling scenarios, the IEA’s World Energy Outlook 2025 estimated that the technology should account for just under 5% of offset emissions by 2050. Recent analysis indicates that we will need a projected 4 gigatonnes of CCS annually by 2035 to keep the globe on track to meet the Paris temperature goals.
The Synthesis Report devoted a few paragraphs to assessing the incorporation of CCS and CDR into the Parties’ NDCs, as well as projections for the next decade. In the context of CCS, the Report concludes that global annual carbon capture reached a record 62 MTCO2 in 2025, up 13% from 2025. The Report also notes that 6% of the Parties had communicated targets to increase annual carbon capture by 2035, with a projected total annual target capacity of 66 MtCO2 by 2035 (para. 194(3)). Regarding carbon removal, the Report noted that 5% of the Parties reported NDC measures for direct air capture, and 2% for bioenergy with carbon capture and storage. This was up modestly from 2 and 1%, respectively, in previous NDCs. In terms of the next decade, 1% of the Parties communicated quantitative targets for 2035, with a total target annual capacity of 14 MtCO2.
However, the Parties to the Paris Agreement are woefully off track in achieving these critical objectives. The projected CCS commitment by the Parties for 2035, set forth in the Report, is a little over 1.5% of what will be needed in 2035 to stay on course for what will be required by the middle of the century. Moreover, the requisite levels of novel, durable CDR would need to scale up by a factor of more than fifty by 2030 to be on track to play its essential role in meeting the Paris temperature targets.
The 2026 edition of UNEP’s annual Emissions Gap Report opens with a “sobering” conclusion: “the opportunity to bridge the 1.5°C emission gap with “no or limited overshoot” has been lost (defined as exceedance of the Paris 1.5°C target by up to 0.1°). The Report contends that the most pressing priority now is to ensure that temperatures remain well below 2°C and to minimise the duration and magnitude of overshoot.
The Report suggests that the lowest 1.5°C overshoot scenario now necessitates “aggregate CO2 removal from the atmosphere.” The Report estimates that reversing the projected 0.15°C overshoot in the central, lowest-1.5 °C overshoot scenario would require 330 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide removal. This scenario contemplates an immediate peaking of greenhouse gas emissions, rapid declines thereafter, and sustained net-negative emissions after net-zero is reached mid-century. Of course, as the Report emphasises, there is a massive “gap” between the emissions-reduction pledges made to date by States and those required to meet the Paris objectives. This will likely substantially ratchet up projected requisite levels of carbon removal over the course of this century and beyond if we’re to avoid severe and protracted climate overshoot.
UNEP’s most recent Emissions Gap Report concluded that the world will exceed the 1.5°C threshold within the next couple of years, and that carefully designed “large-scale” carbon removal programmes are part of the portfolio of responses necessary to limit peak warming and its duration. Yet, it is far from clear that international institutions are seeking to incentivise the requisite buildout of either CCS or CDR.
The UNFCCC Secretariat needs to more urgently communicate the important role of CCS and CDR in combating climate change. Future NDC Synthesis Reports should parallel the approach taken in terms of assessing the emissions of Parties to the Paris Agreement in the context of CCS/CDR, as well as policy measures. Beyond merely reporting on the Parties’ aggregate pledges for CCS and CDR, the report should assess the gap between Parties’ plans in their NDCs and formulate critical benchmarks on the road to multi-gigaton adoption of CCS and CDR technologies. The report should also identify challenges and barriers to meeting these goals, as it does for emissions reductions and energy efficiency. Moreover, it should set forth suggestions for scaling up removals and capture, again, paralleling the approach it takes in the Synthesis report to emissions reductions.
The upcoming second global stocktake in 2028 (as provided for in Article 14 of the Paris Agreement) will assess progress toward achieving the treaty’s overarching objectives and long-term goals. The stocktake should also include assessment of progress to date in scaling up CDR and CCS approaches. In turn, under Article 4(9), the Parties are required to be “informed by the outcomes” in formulating their next round of NDCs, and this should include enacting requisite policy and other measures to ensure scaling of CCS/CDR.
The IPCC’s Methodology Report on Carbon Dioxide Removal Technologies, Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories (Additional guidance) will be released in 2027. It may ultimately provide impetus for additional CDR pledges, as it will provide for guidance on an array of topics, including transportation, injection and storage of carbon dioxide, and coverage of a number of specific pathways, including biochar, direct air capture, enhancing rock weathering, and direct ocean capture.
The UNFCCC has described NDCs as “at the heart of the Paris Agreement,” yet it has given short shrift to the critical role of CDR and CCS NDC commitments in meeting climate goals. Future reports need to do better.
illuminem Voices is a democratic space presenting the opinions of leading Sustainability Thought Leaders, their views do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.
The world needs sustainability knowledge. At illuminem, no interest group or shareholder can influence our work. Thank you for supporting our mission to make high-quality and independent sustainability information free for all. Every contribution helps. Thank you for donating today.
Wil Burns

Carbon Removal · Carbon Capture & Storage
illuminem briefings

Carbon Removal · Corporate Governance
Ioannis Ioannou

Energy Transition · Sustainable Finance
Business Green

Carbon Removal · Public Governance
Carbon Herald

Carbon · Carbon Removal
The Straits Times

Carbon · Carbon Removal