The Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism needs a course correction


· 4 min read
The Article 6.4 Supervisory Body (SBM) has made significant regulatory progress this year, but uptake has not followed.
This is because the SBM is building a mechanism that can only work for a small number of activities and for Parties that are willing to pay very high prices. And to be clear, at the moment there is no Party that is willing to pay these prices. Some might be from 2036, but that is ten years away.
Take clean cooking, for which two methodologies have been adopted by the Supervisory Body last month, though similar arguments apply to every activity type for which PACM methodologies have been approved.
It is a 20x reduction in the volume of credits compared to the CDM; a 70% reduction compared to current best market practices!
These outcomes are not based on science, we should not hide behind it. They also have nothing to do with alleged past over-crediting, which, as the numbers above show, has already been addressed by market participants and standards.
This is a plan to deliver systematic under-crediting and to reject an accurate measurement of emission reductions and removals.
And this is not only about prices. Some activities are prevented altogether from accessing carbon finance based on arbitrary and non-scientific requirements in PACM standards, tools and methodologies.
Just an example – but there are many such cases. Under the Common Practice tool, if the penetration rate of a technology is 16% (or 20% in SIDS and LDC), the activity is deemed non-additional. What is the science behind this? Are we really saying that if 16% of any given population has access to something, there are no barriers to adoption for the remaining 84%?
In one of the cookstove methodologies, the Methodological Expert Panel (MEP) even recommended to impose a hard eligibility cap based on a 4.5% penetration rate, which was fortunately not incorporated in the final version. Again, this is no scientific basis, and the proposal was particularly concerning because the MEP is supposed to make technical recommendations, not policy judgements.
Last week, IETA, together with other organisations, co-signed an open letter to the CMA, articulating our concerns with the current direction of travel and identifying five priorities for guidance at this session. In essence,
This is necessary to ensure that PACM can fulfil its objectives as set out in Article 6.4(a–d) of the Paris Agreement. Unless the mechanism becomes workable across many countries and activity types, its impact on the atmosphere will remain marginal. This version of PACM will not help us achieve NDCs, will not increase ambition, will not take us closer to the goals of the Paris Agreement. Also, a significant correction is the only condition for PACM to become a self-funding mechanism and support the Adaptation Fund.
We were pleased to hear that some of these concerns were shared by Parties making interventions today. We genuinely hope that this will translate into clear guidance to the Supervisory Body, and that the guidance will be implemented by the body and the Secretariat.
This year, despite a clear mandate agreed at COP30 in Belem, there was no material change.
Paragraph 12 of the Belém decision reiterated the need for better governance and management of conflicts of interest for SBM members and individuals serving on expert panels. Yet, there have not been improvements on how conflicts and financial interests are disclosed – when they relate to activities and operational entities, but also when they relate to Parties.
Paragraph 18 of the Belém decision requested the SBM to enhance the transparency of its decision-making and that of the Methodological Expert Panel (MEP). Yet, the SBM only paid lip service to this request. An information note on this item was published only after the meeting, the SBM discussion on this item was held behind closed doors, and the conclusion was that nothing needs to change.
PACM has had a false start, but there is still time to develop rules that investors can act on, a mechanism that can pay for itself, and a process that stakeholders can engage with and trust. Clear guidance from Parties at COP31 would put all three within reach.
IETA and its members stand ready to support Parties and the Supervisory Body with evidence, data and practical experience.
This article is also published on LinkedIn. illuminem Voices is a democratic space presenting the opinions of leading Sustainability Thought Leaders , their views do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.
The world needs sustainability knowledge. At illuminem, no interest group or shareholder can influence our work. Thank you for supporting our mission to make high-quality and independent sustainability information free for all. Every contribution helps. Thank you for donating today.
Andrea Bonzanni

Carbon Regulations · Carbon Market
illuminem

Carbon Regulations · Carbon Market
Samwel Okoth

Corporate Sustainability · Carbon Regulations
Euronews

Carbon Market · Public Governance
Carbon Herald

Carbon Capture & Storage · Carbon Regulations
Phys.org

Carbon · Carbon Regulations