States and startups are suing the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

illuminem summarises for you the essential news of the day. Read the full piece on WIRED or enjoy below:

🗞️ Driving the news: A coalition of nuclear startups and U.S. states has filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), alleging that the agency’s burdensome permitting processes are stifling innovation in the nuclear sector
• The plaintiffs, including Valar Atomics, Deep Fission, and several states, argue that the NRC is exceeding its legal mandate by applying stringent regulations to small modular and microreactors, which they claim are inherently safer and require a more agile regulatory framework

🔭 The context: The lawsuit, initially filed in December 2023, reflects growing frustration with the NRC’s historically slow and adversarial approach to licensing new nuclear technologies
• While the U.S. once led the world in nuclear energy, only three new reactors have launched domestically in the past 25 years, contrasting sharply with rapid nuclear expansion in China and South Korea
• Despite legislative attempts like the ADVANCE Act to modernize NRC processes, industry stakeholders argue that meaningful reform has lagged

🌍 Why it matters for the planet: Nuclear power, especially in smaller forms like SMRs and microreactors, is seen by many as a key component of the clean energy transition, offering zero-carbon baseload power
• However, regulatory gridlock could hamper deployment just as global demand for reliable, non-fossil energy surges 
• Striking the right balance between enabling innovation and maintaining public trust through stringent safety standards remains a critical challenge

⏭️ What's next: The lawsuit seeks to clarify the scope of the NRC’s authority and potentially transfer some regulatory oversight to states — an idea that has drawn both support and concern
• If successful, the case could set a precedent for decentralized nuclear regulation, accelerating the path to deployment for emerging reactor technologies
• A court ruling is expected to shape the next phase of U.S. nuclear policy and innovation

💬 One quote: “We’ve operated reactors so well for so long that a whole new breed of advocates... mistakenly believe that they’re fail-safe by default,” — Nick Touran, nuclear engineer and founder of What Is Nuclear

📈 One stat: NuScale, the only company to receive NRC approval for an SMR design, spent $500 million and 2 million labor hours over several years to gain regulatory clearance — only to cancel its flagship project in 2023 due to escalating costs

See on illuminem's Data Hub™ the sustainability performance of Constellation Energy and its peers Westinghouse Electric, BWX Technologies, and EDF

Click for more news covering the latest on nuclear energy