Before the storm: What California’s state of emergency can teach the world


· 20 min read
In September, California did something that initially sounds contradictory. Governor Gavin Newsom declared a statewide state of emergency for a disaster that had not yet happened. There was no single catastrophic storm approaching the coast and no statewide flood already underway. Instead, the 21 September proclamation responded to the developing 2026–2027 El Niño and the possibility that California could face an unusually severe period of heavy rain, flooding, landslides, coastal erosion, debris flows and other winter disruption.
The declaration allowed state agencies to begin moving resources, protecting vulnerable infrastructure, supporting local governments and preparing emergency personnel before conditions deteriorated. The state directed agencies to stage flood-fighting supplies, prepare roads, accelerate work related to landslides and debris flows and position the California National Guard to assist with engineering, logistics and search-and-rescue operations if required. California was, in effect, using emergency authority to create more options before an emergency removed them.
There is an important distinction here. A pre-emptive emergency declaration does not mean that catastrophe is certain, nor should every severe-weather forecast automatically produce extraordinary government action. It is an acknowledgment that the probability and potential consequences of a hazard can sometimes become significant enough that waiting for certainty creates its own risk. When preparation requires moving equipment, inspecting infrastructure, coordinating agencies and informing millions of people, waiting until everyone agrees that disaster is imminent may mean waiting until some of the most useful opportunities for reducing damage have already disappeared.
That principle deserves attention well beyond California. Governments around the world spend enormous amounts of money responding to disasters after infrastructure has failed, communities have flooded, homes have burned and populations have been displaced. The more difficult challenge is acting while the threat remains uncertain, when preventive investment may look excessive and the benefits of preparation may never become visible precisely because preparation worked.
California therefore provides more than a story about one governor, one state or one El Niño season. It provides a useful case study in anticipatory governance: the ability of institutions to recognise changing conditions, prepare before consequences become unavoidable and give communities and households enough time to act for themselves.
The logic behind California’s action is fundamentally about managing uncertainty. El Niño is a natural climate phenomenon associated with warmer-than-average ocean temperatures in the tropical Pacific and changes in atmospheric circulation. Its effects vary considerably from one event to another, which means even a very strong El Niño cannot tell officials exactly which town will flood, which hillside will fail or how much rain will fall over a particular watershed.
That uncertainty is not an argument against preparation. It is the reason preparedness exists.
Emergency management would be relatively simple if governments knew exactly which disaster would occur, precisely where it would happen, when it would begin and how severe it would become. Real risk rarely provides that level of certainty. Officials instead work with probabilities, exposure, vulnerability and potential consequences, attempting to make decisions while part of the picture remains unknown.
The most important question is therefore not whether every feared consequence will occur. It is whether the potential consequences are serious enough, and the warning credible enough, that taking reasonable precautions today makes more sense than waiting until tomorrow.
California’s September proclamation reflects that calculation. It directed state agencies to protect vulnerable communities, prepare roads and critical infrastructure, support local flood-risk reduction, stage emergency materials and increase coordination before the most dangerous winter conditions arrive. The state also ordered expanded public communication on flooding, evacuation readiness, emergency alerts and power outages, recognising that physical preparedness and public awareness are part of the same system.
The practical preparations are substantial. By early October, California reported that millions of sandbags and other flood-fighting materials were being pre-positioned across the state while approximately 1,600 miles of levees within the State Plan of Flood Control were being inspected. Water infrastructure was being assessed, local governments were being supported and agencies were attempting to position supplies while transportation networks and supply chains were still operating normally.
This is what anticipatory governance looks like. It does not eliminate uncertainty or pretend that forecasting is perfect. It creates capacity while institutions still have time to decide where resources should go.
Emergency declarations are traditionally associated with the period after disaster becomes visible. A wildfire destroys homes, a hurricane reaches land, an earthquake damages infrastructure or a flood overwhelms a community, and government mobilises extraordinary resources in response.
That model will always be necessary because some disasters cannot be anticipated with much warning. Yet where credible warnings do exist, time becomes one of the most valuable resources available to government.
A sandbag stored hundreds of miles away has limited value once water is already entering homes. A rescue team that has not been trained, equipped or positioned cannot instantly become operational when roads begin disappearing beneath floodwater. A community that first begins discussing evacuation routes after its primary road is closed is no longer preparing; it is improvising under pressure.
The same principle applies to households. A family that has not considered where it will go, which medications it needs, how it will transport animals or what it will take from the house may find itself making dozens of decisions simultaneously while an emergency is developing. Those decisions become harder when electricity is out, cellular networks are overloaded, children are frightened and thousands of neighbours are attempting to leave at the same time.
Preparedness is therefore partly about preserving choice. The earlier governments, communities and families act, the more alternatives they retain.
The international evidence for early action is strong. Disaster-risk agencies have increasingly emphasised that warnings save lives only when people and institutions are capable of acting on them. Recent UNDRR analysis of the Lloyd’s Register Foundation World Risk Poll found that among disaster-affected people who received an advance warning, 83% of those who had both a household disaster plan and confidence in their ability to protect themselves were able to take action. Among those who had neither a household plan nor that sense of agency, only 27% were able to act.
The warning itself was not enough. Preparedness determined what people were able to do with the warning.
This is where statewide preparation eventually reaches the front door.
California can position rescue teams, inspect levees and stockpile sandbags, but the state cannot pack a family’s medication or decide which road they will use if they must evacuate. Government preparedness and household preparedness have to work together.
One of the simplest things families can do is prepare emergency go-bags before they are needed. Cal OES specifically advises Californians to prepare a go-bag with essential items for each family member so people can leave quickly when an evacuation becomes necessary.
I would make that preparation as concrete as possible: each member of the household should have their own identifiable emergency bag, packed in advance and stored somewhere that can be reached immediately. If authorities issue an evacuation order, the objective should not be to begin packing. The objective should be to pick up the bags and leave.
Each person’s bag should reflect that individual’s needs. At minimum, families should think about drinking water, nonperishable food, medications, a flashlight, basic first-aid supplies, hygiene items, a phone charger or backup battery, some cash, identification and copies of important documents. Prescription information and other essential medical information should be protected and accessible. Families with children will have additional needs, while anyone caring for an elderly or disabled family member should consider what equipment, medications or assistance that person would require if the household had to leave with very little warning. California’s Family Readiness Guide also recommends emergency water and food, prescription medication, communications equipment, first-aid supplies, local maps, important documents and other essentials that may be needed during evacuation or sheltering.
Animals also need to be incorporated into the plan before evacuation becomes necessary. Pet food, water, leashes, carriers, medication and vaccination information should be prepared rather than gathered during an emergency. Cal OES recommends including pet supplies in emergency preparations because animals can significantly complicate an evacuation when no plan exists for transporting or caring for them.
The purpose of the bag is not to prepare someone to live indefinitely away from home. It is to remove unnecessary decisions during the most dangerous period of an emergency. If a wildfire changes direction, a river rises faster than expected or authorities suddenly expand an evacuation area, a household should be able to move in minutes rather than spend those minutes searching for medication, paperwork and basic necessities.
The location of the bags matters for the same reason. Emergency supplies buried in the back of a garage underneath other possessions may technically exist, but they are not truly evacuation-ready. Bags should be accessible, family members should know where they are kept, and they should be reviewed periodically so medications, food, batteries and documents remain current.
A go-bag solves only part of the problem. A household also needs to know how it will leave.
Cal OES recommends learning multiple evacuation routes rather than depending on a single familiar road. That advice matters because emergencies frequently disrupt the transportation system itself. Flooding can close low-lying roads, landslides can block mountain highways, wildfire can cross established evacuation routes and emergency vehicles may require authorities to redirect civilian traffic.
Families should therefore know more than one way out of their neighbourhood and have a general idea of where they could go under different circumstances. They should know where family members will meet if an emergency happens while people are at work or school, and children should know how to contact appropriate adults. An out-of-area contact can also be useful if local communication becomes difficult.
People who know they will require additional time should act earlier rather than later. Families transporting livestock, people with disabilities, elderly residents and households without reliable transportation may not be able to respond at the same speed as someone who can simply get into a vehicle and drive away. Preparedness means recognising those differences before an evacuation order compresses everyone’s available time.
Flooding introduces another danger because people routinely underestimate moving water. California emergency officials repeatedly warn residents not to walk or drive through floodwater. What appears shallow from inside a vehicle can conceal damaged pavement, washed-out roads or a current strong enough to move a vehicle. A decision to turn around may feel inconvenient, but it is far better than converting a transportation problem into a rescue operation.
Individual preparedness has limits. Communities contain people with very different abilities to respond to the same warning.
An emergency alert sent simultaneously to thousands of phones does not create equal capacity among the people receiving it. One resident may have two vehicles, savings, relatives nearby and flexible employment. Another may be elderly, live alone and no longer drive. A family may understand an evacuation order perfectly but have nowhere affordable to stay. Someone may rely on electrically powered medical equipment or require medication that cannot simply be replaced at the last moment.
This is why community resilience is more than a collection of individual emergency kits. Neighbours should know who around them might need assistance. Families can exchange contact information with trusted people nearby, discuss who has transportation and consider whether an elderly or vulnerable neighbour may need someone to check on them when conditions deteriorate.
The same principle applies to government communication. Warnings must be accessible, understandable and available in multiple languages and formats because a warning that never reaches part of the population is an incomplete warning system. California’s emergency proclamation specifically directs agencies to expand accessible and multilingual preparedness communications, acknowledging that information is useful only when people can receive and understand it.
Preparedness is therefore partly physical and partly social. Sandbags, generators and emergency bags matter, but so do relationships, communication and trust.
One of the most important lessons in disaster preparedness is that risk is experienced locally even when the underlying hazard covers an enormous geographic area.
California is geographically and climatically diverse. A winter storm that produces manageable rainfall in one community can create flash flooding in another, dangerous snow in the mountains, coastal erosion elsewhere and debris flows below a wildfire burn scar. State government can coordinate resources, but local agencies understand which roads flood first, which neighbourhoods have limited access, where drainage systems repeatedly fail and which residents may be particularly vulnerable.
This is why preparedness must operate at several levels simultaneously. State government can mobilise large resources and remove administrative barriers. Counties and cities translate those resources into local operations. Utilities protect essential infrastructure. Emergency managers communicate with the public. Households then make the final decisions about how and when to act.
None of these layers can substitute completely for the others.
A government may issue an excellent warning, but a household without a plan can still lose valuable time. A family may be well prepared, but preparation has limits if critical infrastructure fails across an entire region. A local government may understand its risks clearly but lack the financial or logistical resources available to a state or national government.
Resilience emerges when these different levels reinforce rather than contradict one another.
The difference between receiving a warning and actually being capable of acting on it is not unique to California.
Around the world, countries have invested heavily in weather forecasting, satellites, telecommunications and disaster-warning technology. These advances have saved countless lives, but technological forecasting solves only one part of the problem. A warning must reach people early enough, they must trust it, they must understand what action is expected and they must possess enough resources to take that action.
The recent UNDRR evidence demonstrates how significant that final step can be. Among people who had experienced disasters and received advance warning, the presence of both a household plan and confidence in their ability to respond was associated with a dramatically greater likelihood of taking protective action. This tells us something important about the architecture of resilience: information matters, but information without capacity can leave people aware of danger while still unable to escape it.
A coastal resident may know a cyclone is approaching but lack transportation. A farmer may receive a drought forecast but lack the credit required to change crops or secure additional water. A family may understand that flooding is likely but live in housing they cannot reinforce and have nowhere else to go. Disaster preparedness therefore intersects with poverty, infrastructure, transportation, housing, public health and social protection.
This is particularly important for global development. Poorer households often possess the fewest resources for absorbing shocks even though a disaster may represent a much larger proportion of everything they own. Losing a home, harvest, vehicle or small business can erase years of progress, and recovery may require borrowing or selling assets in ways that increase vulnerability to the next disaster.
California possesses resources that many governments around the world do not. It can stockpile millions of sandbags, deploy sophisticated emergency-management systems, conduct large-scale infrastructure inspections and draw upon substantial technical capacity. It would be unrealistic to suggest that every government can simply reproduce California’s system.
The underlying principle, however, is highly transferable.
Every community can ask what can be done today that will become dramatically harder once the hazard arrives. A village without sophisticated flood barriers can still identify high ground and evacuation routes before the rainy season. A coastal community can establish warning networks and determine where people will shelter. A school can maintain contact information and identify children requiring additional assistance. Farmers can share forecast information through trusted local networks. Governments can identify hospitals, bridges, power systems and water facilities whose failure would cause the greatest cascading disruption.
Households can do the same at a smaller scale. Emergency bags cost far less than emergency evacuation under chaotic conditions. Knowing several routes costs nothing. Agreeing on a meeting place requires only a conversation. Keeping medication and critical documents organised can prevent hours of difficulty after evacuation.
The technologies and financial resources available will differ enormously between California, Bangladesh, Tunisia, Kenya, the Philippines or a small island state, but the question remains remarkably similar: what can we prepare while time is still available?
El Niño itself is a natural climate phenomenon, and it would be inaccurate to describe California’s current El Niño simply as a product of climate change. Natural climate variability existed long before industrial greenhouse-gas emissions.
Climate change matters because it changes the environmental background within which natural variability occurs. Infrastructure was usually designed using assumptions derived from historical conditions. Storm drains reflect expected rainfall rates. Bridges reflect assumptions about river flows. Electrical systems reflect historical temperature and demand patterns. Coastal infrastructure reflects past relationships between storms, waves and sea levels.
When the background conditions change, historical averages become less reliable as a complete guide to future extremes.
Governments cannot rebuild every piece of infrastructure every time a forecast changes, nor should every imaginable worst-case scenario become the basis for unlimited spending. Resources remain finite. The challenge is identifying which systems are most consequential, where existing vulnerability is already high and where reasonable investment can create enough additional capacity to prevent localised failure from becoming systemic.
California’s pre-emptive emergency declaration reflects this philosophy. The state is not claiming that every community will flood or that every forecast will prove correct. It is positioning resources and increasing institutional readiness because enough evidence exists to justify greater preparation than would otherwise occur.
That is risk management rather than prediction.
One persistent weakness in development planning around the world has been the tendency to treat disaster preparedness as something separate from development itself.
We describe roads, schools, electrical grids, hospitals and water systems as development investments, while emergency planning is sometimes treated as an additional activity surrounding them. Yet a road that predictably becomes unusable during flooding is not fully resilient infrastructure. A hospital that cannot maintain critical services when the electricity fails contains an unresolved vulnerability. A water system that cannot tolerate foreseeable drought conditions is not simply a water project; it is a future emergency waiting for the right conditions.
Preparedness should therefore be designed into infrastructure rather than attached to it afterwards. The least expensive time to improve drainage may be while the road is being constructed. The easiest moment to preserve an evacuation route is before development blocks it. The most effective time to establish backup communications is before the primary network has failed.
This becomes particularly important as cities expand rapidly. Decisions made today about housing, transportation, water, electricity and land use can embed vulnerability into urban systems for decades. Anticipatory governance asks planners to recognise that some future disaster losses are created by present development decisions, just as many future losses can be reduced by present investments in resilience.
There is something conceptually important about declaring an emergency before the anticipated disaster has fully materialised. It changes emergency management from an activity focused primarily on response into one that also recognises the value of anticipation.
This does not mean emergency powers should become routine or permanent. Extraordinary authorities carry consequences and should remain proportional to the threat, subject to appropriate oversight and terminated when they are no longer necessary. Preparedness and accountability should reinforce one another rather than compete.
What California’s declaration demonstrates is that uncertainty does not always justify waiting. Sometimes credible risk, serious potential consequences and the amount of time required to prepare justify action before the final outcome is known. Governments make versions of this calculation constantly, whether confronting storms, wildfire, pandemics, drought, financial instability or geopolitical disruptions. The quality of governance is partly determined by whether institutions can distinguish between uncertain risks that justify preparation and speculation that does not.
The same logic applies at the household level. A family does not need to know that an evacuation order will definitely arrive before preparing emergency bags. The very purpose of those bags is that the family does not know exactly when they will be needed. Their value comes from being ready before anyone is forced to use them.
Disaster resilience is frequently associated with its most visible moments: firefighters confronting flames, helicopters conducting rescues, crews moving through floodwater and governments announcing reconstruction programmes after catastrophe. Those actions are essential, but much of what determines their eventual success was established long before cameras arrived.
Resilience is built when levees are inspected during ordinary weather, when drains are cleared before heavy rain, when emergency agencies coordinate before roads close and when communities identify vulnerable residents before an evacuation begins. At the household level, it is built when a family makes a plan, checks several possible routes, keeps important documents together and places an emergency bag for every member of the household somewhere it can be grabbed immediately.
None of those actions are dramatic, and ideally many of them will never produce a dramatic story. That is part of the difficulty of investing in preparedness. Successful prevention is often invisible. The road remains open, the family evacuates safely, the power returns quickly or the flood barrier holds, and the event never becomes as catastrophic as it might otherwise have been.
That absence of catastrophe should not be mistaken for evidence that preparation was unnecessary. In resilient systems, the disaster that did not escalate may be the most important outcome of all.
For Californians, the immediate lesson is straightforward. Understand the hazards around where you live, register for local warnings, monitor credible forecasts, know more than one route out of your neighbourhood and talk with the people you live with about what you will do if conditions suddenly change. Most importantly, prepare before the warning arrives. Every person in the household should have an emergency bag ready enough that, if authorities say it is time to go, the household can pick up those bags and leave rather than beginning to decide what matters while the danger is already approaching.
For communities elsewhere in the world, the specific hazard may be entirely different. It may be a cyclone approaching South Asia, a flood threatening an African city, wildfire in the Mediterranean, extreme heat in the Middle East, drought affecting farmers in East Africa or a landslide threatening a mountain community. The institutional capacity and resources available will also differ enormously, but the underlying principle does not change. Communities should identify the hazards they face, establish ways of communicating before communications are disrupted, determine who will need additional assistance and position whatever resources they possess while transportation and institutions are still functioning.
The most important lesson from California’s pre-emptive state of emergency is therefore not about California alone. It is about the relationship between uncertainty and action. Governments should not need certainty of disaster before performing reasonable preparations, just as households should not wait for an evacuation order before determining what they will take with them. In both cases, the objective is to preserve choices while choices still exist.
A warning is valuable only when someone is capable of responding to it, and preparedness is what turns information into action. That requires governments able to anticipate, communities able to coordinate and households capable of moving when circumstances demand it. None can provide complete resilience alone, but together they create layers of protection that make it more difficult for an extreme event to become a human catastrophe.
California’s developing El Niño may ultimately produce conditions that are less severe than some forecasts suggest, or impacts may be concentrated in particular regions rather than across the entire state. That uncertainty does not undermine the logic of preparation. It illustrates it. Emergency planning is not based on knowing exactly what will happen; it exists because we do not.
The larger lesson is one that societies everywhere will increasingly need to understand as climate risks, urban growth and infrastructure interdependence make disasters more complex. Preparedness should not begin when the floodwater is rising, the fire is approaching or evacuation routes are already congested. It should begin during the quiet period beforehand, when families can pack, governments can coordinate, infrastructure can be inspected and communities can decide how they will protect the people most likely to need help.
That is the real significance of a state of emergency declared before the emergency. It is an acknowledgment that the most valuable moment for reducing disaster risk is often the period when disaster still seems uncertain and ordinary life is continuing around us. Those are the moments when governments, communities and individuals have the greatest number of options, and the decisions made during that period may determine how much remains intact when the storm finally arrives.
illuminem Voices is a democratic space presenting the opinions of leading Sustainability Thought Leaders, their views do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.
The world needs sustainability knowledge. At illuminem, no interest group or shareholder can influence our work. Thank you for supporting our mission to make high-quality and independent sustainability information free for all. Every contribution helps. Thank you for donating today.
Abbas Kazmi

Climate Change · Adaptation
Steven W. Pearce

Climate Change · Adaptation
Shuwei Zhang

Coal · Energy
ABC News

Climate Change · Public Governance
The Guardian

Climate Change · Environmental Sustainability
earth.com

Climate Change