background image

China Inc has energy choices other than coal

author image

By Philippe Benoit

· 2 min read

The FT reports China’s new coal power plants are uneconomic (Report,, June 30). However, what may seem “uneconomic” under a traditional plant-level analysis is potentially attractive from the country-level economic perspective that is arguably more relevant for China, particularly given the prevalence of state-owned enterprises.

China’s power producers, as well as construction companies, coal suppliers and utilities, are generally affiliated SOEs within what can be described as “China Inc”. Prices for inputs and outputs faced by producers are principally determined through government regulations and “non-arms-length” transactions between two SOEs. And it is largely this government-driven pricing scheme which creates the FT-referenced “stranded assets” risk for SOEs on their new plants.


But, at its core, power generation is one activity within the broader effort of China Inc to grow the country’s economy and maintain government control over strategic assets. A preliminary analysis I co-authored (under a programme studying SOEs and climate action) indicates new coal plants can indeed generate an economic benefit for China given the value of electricity to consumers and assuming local environmental impacts are managed. However, the analysis also indicates that incorporating a moderate carbon price on plant emissions would eliminate this benefit, thereby rendering the project uneconomic from China’s perspective. Investing in renewables potentially provides a stronger economic return.

China may be overinvesting in new coal generation, but the key marker is less that these plants are unprofitable for the SOE owner, but rather that China Inc has better alternative power investments to make to advance the country’s economic interests.

Energy Voices is a democratic space presenting the thoughts and opinions of leading Energy & Sustainability writers, their opinions do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.

Did you enjoy this illuminem voice? Support us by sharing this article!
author photo

About the author

Philippe Benoit is the Managing Director for Global Infrastructure Advisory Services 2050. He also served as Division Head of the IEA's Energy Environment and Energy Efficiency Divisions, and as Energy Sector Manager at the World Bank. In addition, Philippe previously worked as an investment banker and corporate lawyer focusing on energy.

Other illuminem Voices

Related Posts

You cannot miss it!

Weekly. Free. Your Top 10 Sustainability & Energy Posts.

You can unsubscribe at any time (read our privacy policy)