You can’t miss it!

Weekly. Free. Your Top 10 Sustainability & Energy Posts.

Your name

Your email

Your company

Your position

You can unsubscribe at any time (read our privacy policy.)

Join us

Why climate change is the symptom of a much deeper and bigger problem?
Why climate change is the symptom of a much deeper and bigger problem?
Benjamin Casteillo
By Benjamin Casteillo
May 25 2022 · 6 min read

Illuminem Voices
Sustainability · Climate Change · Mitigation

We are Facing much more than just Climate Change, and it is time that we acknowledge it

Climate change, fossil fuel and greenhouse game emissions are receiving increasing media attention in the west thanks to climate activists and a meteorology that records peak temperature at an increasing rate. As a result, more and more pledges are being made to tackle the problem, by governments, companies and organisations. For example, Jeff Bezos recently donated billions of dollars to “fight climate change”. If all these efforts are signs that steps are being taken to tackle a global threat that could seriously jeopardize the future of humanity, it appears that our efforts to overcome the great challenge of our times are hindered by a lack of understanding of its nature, its underlying causes and its solution.

Figure 1: Photo credit: Chris LeBoutillier - Unsplash
Figure 1: Photo credit: Chris LeBoutillier - Unsplash

In fact, climate change appears to not be not the only ecological problem we are facing, a growing number of alarming scientific reports point at the overconsumption of our planetary resources, the destruction of the ecosystems, the pollution of oil, water, soil and what is being called the 6th mass extinction which indicate that we are in the process of destroying the conditions that make our existence possible. To better understand what is taking place, it is important to take a step back and look at the bigger picture using two key indicators: humanity ecological footprint and earth biocapacity.

Humanity’s ecological footprint stands for the impact of human activities on earth:

  • The amount of resources extracted
  • The quantity of pollution released
  • The damaged dealt to the planet ecosystems

Earth biocapacity in the other hand stands for our planet ecosystems ability to absorb this impact:

  • The amount of resources generated
  • The quantity of pollution absorbed
  • The rate of regeneration of the ecosystems

When humanity’s ecological footprint offsets earth biocapacity, we are in a situation described as an overshoot of our planetary limits

  • Humanity extracts more resources than can be sustainably generated
  • More pollution is released than what the planet ecosystems are able to absorb
  • The ecosystems are being destroyed at a faster rate than they are regenerated
Figure 2: Understanding what a planetary overshoot is
Figure 2: Understanding what a planetary overshoot is

Climate change is just the symptom of a bigger ecological problem: the overshoot of our planetary limits. If we don’t resolve it, we are going to face an ecological disaster of planetary scale with unprecedented catastrophic consequences. To avoid it, we have no other choice but to integrate our planetary limits and achieve a global sustainable transition.

Although it is common to consider sustainability while focusing only on ecological issues, it is very unlikely to be an effective approach to achieve the sustainable transition. We are not only facing an aggravating critical ecological situation, we are also facing major socio-economic and political issues: a growing human population, extreme poverty and famines, rising inequalities, increasing financial debts, out of control inflation, geopolitical tensions and an increasingly polarized population. What we are dealing with is not just climate change or an ecological emergency, but a multifactorial systemic and global crisis of sustainability. All these issues are not separated from one another but interrelated. Unfortunately, we haven’t yet reached the collective level of awareness needed to properly define the problem which is hindering our ability to conceive of realistic solutions. If “a problem well stated is a problem half solved” as per Charles Kettering quotes, a problem unproperly stated is a problem that we can’t even start solving.

Figure 3: The problem with Climate Change tunnel vision
Figure 3: The problem with Climate Change tunnel vision

To resolve a systemic and global crisis of sustainability, it is key to identify and treat its underlying causes. It is undeniable that whether they are socio-economic or ecological, all the factors of unsustainability share one common denominator: they are all the result of certain human behavior patterns.

Figure 4: The common denominator between all the factors of global and systemic unsustainability
Figure 4: The common denominator between all the factors of global and systemic unsustainability

And it is not difficult to guess what foster them. Our global economy built on the pursuit of the American dream is materialist, consumerist and productivist. It is based on ruthless competition for short term profits, unlimited accumulation of capital and growth. On a finite planet, such economic system can only lead to the overexploitation and destruction of the ecosystems. What we are experiencing is a predictable overshoot of our planetary limits: a global scale tragedy of the commons in which the earth vital resources are being overconsumed in order to feed self-perpetuating rivalries for power, wealth and status. The global and systemic problem we are facing is not technological or technical but human and created by carelessness, ignorance and greed.

The global and systemic crisis of sustainability we are facing is reminding us about disregarded lessons of ancient wisdom about the importance of empathy, ponderation and solidarity which under these new circumstances appear as vital quality to nurture and develop for our human species to become sustainable. And to learn that very precious lesson, we must collectively find the courage and maturity to recognize that the problem we are trying to solve outside of ourselves, find its roots within ourselves.

Figure 5: Meme widely shared on social media featuring a quote attributed to Gus Speth and speaking about the need to recognize the human origin behind the global and systemic crisis of sustainability
Figure 5: Meme widely shared on social media featuring a quote attributed to Gus Speth and speaking about the need to recognize the human origin behind the global and systemic crisis of sustainability

We are not there yet as all the dominant systems of power appear to support the unsustainable status quo. While we are approaching a tipping point and a global disaster, our politicians are busy perpetuating and optimizing the GDP growth, our medias are placing our attention on mundane stories and superficialities, our social media use the best of artificial intelligence to keep us hooked, employees are burning themselves out doing mostly meaningless jobs, and we are constantly bombarding ourselves with advertisements to consume always more so that we can feed our collective addiction to GDP growth.

Before we can do anything, we might need to collectively acknowledged that we have kept ourselves entertained and distracted away from an impending global crisis of sustainability. As long as we unconsciously chose to keep ourselves and one another in a state of denial, escapism and apathy, we will continue on our path towards planetary disaster. Undeniably, facing this situation will require a certain level of mental and emotional maturity ad it challenges our beliefs and certainties. And to encourage ourselves it is important to remind that feeling temporarily feeling distress and overwhelmed is part of the process, before we can grasp the grasp the magnitude of the problem and set ourselves in the conditions needed to move toward the solution.

As much as all of this this might seem very depressing and overwhelming, we would be lying to ourselves if we were saying that we are facing is a problem without solution. We would be also quiet blind not to see the opportunity within the challenge. In fact, addressing the underlying cause of the crisis of sustainability implies profound changes and therefore an opportunity to reinvent ourselves and our society for the better.

The global and systemic crisis of sustainability that we are facing is not only a great danger but also a great opportunity for evolution and positive change. It is trying to teach us a lesson as we are all invited to learn how to take care of ourselves, one another and our planet. What a better time to start than now?

Energy Voices is a democratic space presenting the thoughts and opinions of leading Energy & Sustainability writers, their opinions do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.

Did you enjoy this energy voice? Support us by sharing this article!

Benjamin Casteillo
About the author

Benjamin is an ex-corporate senior Manager who has founded New World Together: an Interdisciplinary Research and Education project dedicated to pioneer Global Sustainability with Human Centered Solutions through Mindshifts and Behavior Changes.

Other Illuminem Voices

How To Spot “Mainstream” Climate Propaganda
Brad Zarnett
Brad Zarnett
Aug 11 2022
How To Spot “Mainstream” Climate Propaganda
It’s Getting Hot: 19 Strategies That Can Help Our Planet To Cool Down
Dr. Erlijn van Genuchten
Dr. Erlijn van Genuchten
Aug 11 2022
It’s Getting Hot: 19 Strategies That Can Help Our Planet To Cool Down